I spent four years, my “tour of duty,” in Christian Radio here in Dallas before answering the call into church communications and ministry marketing. One thing that’s true about media in general is that it’s all about money. Big money. The station making money, and advertisers making money, so that advertisers will spend even more money with the station.
Before you get sucked into some grandiose promises from your Account Executive and spend a lot of money on your advertising – even if you’re convinced you have an awesome campaign idea – please read the rest of this post.
Here’s the truth: Advertising doesn’t work. That’s what we told all of our potential advertisers to our station. And it doesn’t matter which medium(s) you choose – radio, television, newspaper, banner ads, billboards, direct mail – it just doesn’t matter.
Here’s the whole truth: It’s not the advertising itself that’s working. It’s the offer you make that’s either working or not working.
Before you even consider advertising, the starting place for your marketing goal is to determine the offer you’re making to your audience. By the way, “awareness” is not a marketing goal. Awareness campaigns, unless you’re a brand new church plant or have just relocated, are for lazy thinkers. For more on that subject, see my earlier post.
Begin with one offer – one truthful promise you can deliver – and build your strategy from there. Keep your offer simple, tangible, and real.
How do you do that? Good question. Here’s something to ask yourself: What are you best at? But not four or five things. That one thing. Just one. Focus on one campaign at a time. Refer to your singular driving vision and purpose. Look to your greatest strength rather than a hodge-podge mix of mediocre strengths and potential weaknesses.
- Do you offer a welcoming, loving community?
- Do you offer the chance to impact your local community? The world?
- Does every Sunday message inspire, challenge, motivate, and mobilize a force for effective change?
- Do you have an effective homeless ministry?
- Do you have an incredible Small Groups emphasis for growth, fellowship and discipleship?
- Is your worship music out-of-the-park awesome?
- Is your children’s ministry the best in the city?
- Does your student ministry help kids grow into passionate disciples?
- Is a partnership with a local crisis pregnancy center making a positive difference?
- Do you have a counseling center that is helping save marriages from the brink of divorce and restore a Christ-centered relationship?
- Can your church report more people coming into a relationship with Jesus Christ and the greatest measurement of life transformation than any other church around?
Today’s consumers are bombarded, jaded, cynical, skeptical, protective, and defensive. Yes, even other Christians. You’ve gotta make it a simple, compelling offer. I’m convinced that it would be incredibly poor stewardship to throw money at something that won’t provide a good return on investment (ROI). I’ll even go so far as to say that if you can’t identify one singular offer, don’t advertise.
I’d love to know your thoughts.